Sunday, November 29, 2009

Arf and the Three Dogs

Philip Wooderson. Illustrated by Bridget MacKeith. London: A&C Black Publishers, 2002. ISBN: 0-7136-6272-7

Plot Summary: Arf is a young boy saving up for a new computer game.He decides that we will work as a news reporter to earn some extra money. He decides to find out more information about "Barmy Barney" and his terrible dogs. Arf even "borrows" his mothers camera as he feels a picture of the man in action will guarantee him a story in the paper if it is accompanies by a picture. He finally manages to get a snap of the three dogs looking vicious. Eventually he must decide whom to sell the photos to as he becomes involved with local doggie politics.

Critical Evaluation:
While the story is fast paced and interesting to read, the illustrations really don't add anything to the plot or the enjoyment of the story. While it is in graphic format, it may be more enjoyable without the illustrations. The illustrations are very simple and cartoonish and really don't do a good job of portraying facial expressions or emotions making this more of a cartoon book rather than a graphic novel.

Reader's Annotation: Arf is determined to make some extra money. He takes some pictures of three vicious looking dogs and suddenly become a part of a doggie scandal.

About the Author: Philip Wooderson is the author of over 20 books for youth. He has written several graphic novels and also historical fiction for tweens.

Genre:
Graphic Novel
Curriculum ties: None
Challenge Issues: Some may object to the genre of graphic novels. To defend, suggest they research the genre or recommend some award winning examples of the genre of graphic novels.
Interest Level: 8-12 years old
Booktalking Ideas:
Do you like solving mysteries and writing about them? Arf is a boy who did just that.
Focus on character of bossy older sister.
Selection Process: On display at library

No comments:

Post a Comment